Current:Home > BackMissouri lawsuit accusing China of hoarding pandemic gear can proceed, appeals panel says-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
Missouri lawsuit accusing China of hoarding pandemic gear can proceed, appeals panel says
View Date:2024-12-23 21:07:07
JEFFERSON CITY, Mo. (AP) — A Missouri lawsuit accusing China of hoarding masks and other protective gear during the COVID-19 pandemic can move forward, federal judges ruled Wednesday.
A panel of the U.S. Eighth District Court of Appeals panel, however, otherwise agreed with a lower court’s 2022 ruling that tossed out Missouri’s case entirely, finding that federal rules prohibit a sovereign foreign entity from being sued in American courts. The state alleged that China’s officials were to blame for the pandemic because they didn’t do enough to slow its spread.
The appeals panel found that only one claim may proceed: an allegation that China hoarded personal protective equipment.
“Missouri’s overarching theory is that China leveraged the world’s ignorance about COVID-19,” Judge David Stras wrote in the ruling. “One way it did so was by manipulating the worldwide personal-protective-equipment market. Missouri must still prove it, but it has alleged enough to allow the claim to proceed beyond a jurisdictional dismissal on the pleadings.”
Chief Judge Lavenski Smith dissented, writing that the whole lawsuit should be dismissed.
“Immunity for foreign states under the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act, while not impenetrable, is quite stout and stronger than the claim alleged in this case,” Smith wrote. “It is certainly not strong enough to justify judicial intervention into an arena well populated with substantial political and diplomatic concerns.”
Missouri Republican Attorney General Andrew Bailey, whose office filed the lawsuit, lauded the ruling Wednesday on X, formerly known as Twitter.
“We are headed back to court to pursue remedies,” he posted.
The lawsuit, filed in April 2020, alleged that Chinese officials were “responsible for the enormous death, suffering, and economic losses they inflicted on the world, including Missourians.”
Neither the Chinese government nor any other Chinese defendant named in the case has responded to the lawsuit in court.
The Lawyers for Upholding International Law and The China Society of Private International Law filed briefs defending China against the lawsuit. Associated Press emails and voice messages left with lawyers for the groups were not immediately returned Wednesday.
China has criticized the lawsuit as “very absurd” and said it has no factual and legal basis. Legal experts have mostly panned it as a stunt aimed at shifting blame to China for the COVID-19 pandemic.
veryGood! (12)
Related
- Ex-Marine misused a combat technique in fatal chokehold of NYC subway rider, trainer testifies
- Henry Shaw
- N. Richard Werthamer
- How Georgia reduced heat-related high school football deaths
- Knicks Player Ogugua Anunoby Nearly Crashes Into Anne Hathaway and Her Son During NBA Game
- Billie Lourd Calls Out Carrie Fisher’s Siblings for Public “Attacks” in Rare Statement
- Patrick Mahomes' Brother Jackson Mahomes Arrested for Alleged Aggravated Sexual Battery
- Europe’s Hot, Fiery Summer Linked to Global Warming, Study Shows
- Detroit-area police win appeal over liability in death of woman in custody
- Long COVID and the labor market
Ranking
- Police cruiser strikes and kills a bicyclist pulling a trailer in Vermont
- Cisco Rolls Out First ‘Connected Grid’ Solution in Major Smart Grid Push
- Lee Raymond
- Resolution Opposing All New Fossil Fuel Infrastructure Passes in Portland
- Demure? Brain rot? Oxford announces shortlist for 2024 Word of the Year: Cast your vote
- Today’s Climate: April 29, 2010
- Fracking Studies Overwhelmingly Indicate Threats to Public Health
- Today’s Climate: May 8-9, 2010
Recommendation
-
Tom Brady Admits He Screwed Up as a Dad to Kids With Bridget Moynahan and Gisele Bündchen
-
Trump Nominee to Lead Climate Agency Supported Privatizing U.S. Weather Data
-
Military jets scrambled due to unresponsive small plane over Washington that then crashed in Virginia
-
Vanderpump Rules' Explosive Teaser Shows Tom Sandoval & Raquel Leviss Together Again
-
'Wanted' posters plastered around University of Rochester target Jewish faculty members
-
How has your state's abortion law affected your life? Share your story
-
‘People Are Dying’: Puerto Rico Faces Daunting Humanitarian Crisis
-
The Michigan supreme court set to decide whether voters see abortion on the ballot